2110-6-8-25

The University, St. Andrews.

From Sir James Colquhoun Irvine, Principal and Vice-Chancellor.

1st October 1934.

My dear John,

From the time the "Cromwell" notices began to appear I made the excellent resolution that I would write and tell you of my pleasure in hearing a friend's work praised so highly. And, of course, I did nothing of the kind; but all to the good for now I need no longer depend on the reviewers. "Every bit as good as Montrose" was my first impression, based largely on a straightforward reading, "Even better than Montrose" is a more mature opinion giving credit to what I imagine was the greater difficulty of the Cromwell task. If I were you I would be well content to have them equated and in any case I congratulate you.

"The Free Fishers" awaited my return here and its friendly inscription makes it a valued possession. So far, one reading only but a second will follow soon for I was greatly interested in the period Scots you use with so much skill; also I have a feeling that I want to get to know your Professor as intimately as I do David Balfour of Shaws. Very many thanks for writing what is much more than an adventure yarn.

Judging from a letter from T.J., the Pilgrim Trust Chairmanship problem is apparently solved. In my reply to him I ventured the suggestion that S.B. might resume the chair when he ceases to have Cabinet rank: think it over. During the vacation I've had a stiff time with E.S.H. and had to end by quoting our friend Dr Johnson "it's very hard to please a man against his will".

The family joins in greetings,

Affectionately yours

J.C. Irvine.